SiftedAI Copilot Live Demo: Expand Your Parcel Oversight Without Adding Headcount Register

Sifted logo

Carrier Management: Critical Functions and Why It’s Important

Feb 28, 2023

8 min read

What Is Carrier Management?

Carrier management is important for healthy operations and relationships between the shipper and the carrier. One of the ways to organize this is using by using Logistics Intelligence to help resolve challenges with obtaining the right carriers and monitoring their performance.

In addition, carrier management bridges the gap between the shipper and the carrier to ensure smoother movement of shipments. It helps businesses anticipate events and issues proactively to overcome obstacles and maximize successful outcomes.

In this article, we’ll discuss the importance of effective carrier management for shippers and review best practices and tools to help you measure carrier performance and reduce shipping costs.

 

Why Carrier Management is Important for Shippers

Here are several ways a carrier management system can help you improve your shipping and fulfillment operations:

  • Monitor and benchmark carrier performance: If you utilize a multi-carrier strategy to fulfill customer orders, a carrier management system can help you seamlessly integrate carriers to track and compare their performance from a single place. It can also reveal important insights about shipping speed and costs. With this information, you can build and continuously improve your carrier network.
  • Audit shipping invoices: Transportation spending accounts for 10% of your product’s cost. Errors and inaccuracies in shipping invoices can significantly hurt your profit margins. Effective carrier management helps you identify invoice discrepancies in fees and surcharges and share them with your carrier to request refunds for errors or failure to meet promised service delivery.
  • Stay on top of shipping delays: 93% of customers want proactive updates from sellers about their orders. A carrier management tool lets you monitor all your delivery events from a central hub in real time and share tracking updates with your customers. This way, you can notify customers about potential delays in a timely manner and give them an estimate of when to expect their package.

 

Critical Functions of Carrier Management

Below, we’ll go over some of the best tools and metrics that can help you make the most out of your shipping operations.

Carrier Scorecards

Carrier scorecards can help shippers better understand their supply chain, offering greater visibility into their transportation operations and creating more accurate delivery estimates. Carrier scorecards give shippers a holistic view of their carrier performance and reflect compliance with the shipping contract.

The carrier landscape has changed in recent years. Shipping costs are rising, freight capacity is shrinking, and shipments are experiencing frequent delays. This doesn’t just affect the shippers, but it also hurts customer satisfaction as demand grows.

Although shippers don’t enjoy the same leverage they did in the past, carrier accountability to key metrics must be a cornerstone of any company’s eCommerce shipping strategy. Tracking logistics KPIs is vital to supply chain optimization, increasing revenues, and improving the bottom line.

A few of the KPIs that are measured include:

  • On-time delivery performance
  • Accurate invoicing
  • Response time
  • Customer service responsiveness
  • Carrier capacity
  • Carrier load preferences (such as full-truckload (FTL), less-than-truckload (LTL), small parcel, etc.)
  • Carrier service levels
  • Routing compliance
  • Number of damage-free shipments

According to the 2021 MHI Annual Industry study, 31% of supply chain managers use prescriptive and predictive analytics to make their processes more efficient. Shippers can benefit from implementing carrier scorecard initiatives that apply predictive modeling to forecast challenges and determine solutions to overcome them.

Sifted Score uses machine learning (ML) algorithms to detect trends and anomalies in your shipping data. It measures the performance of your shipping operations across 20+ factors and summarizes them in a single score.

Shipping Volume Visibility Management

Carriers offer discounted pricing to shippers based on their volume of shipments. With shipping contracts, there are two main types of discounts: guaranteed and tier-based discounts (based on the average volume over the past 52 months).

Often, shipping companies don’t apply volume discounts by mistake. Furthermore, shipping carriers impose penalties when shippers divert shipping volume and fall below contractually pre-set levels. This means you must proactively track your shipping volume to ensure you don’t fall into a lower, more expensive tier. To achieve this, you’ll need to shift more volume to that carrier the next month to not lose your discount.

Sifted’s contract monitoring tool in the carrier management suite alerts shippers when they’re at risk of dropping below a volume threshold for discounts.

Carrier relationships are the backbone of your fulfillment operations. Shippers must closely examine their contract and pricing agreements and validate carrier invoices against negotiated rates and discounts to uncover discrepancies.

FBA vs FBM

The #1 Logistics Intelligence Software

Claims Management

Managing claims properly is vital to the success of small and large-volume shippers. You must stay active throughout the claims process, from filing a claim early to staying in regular contact with the carrier and insurance company.

The process of filing claims, getting them approved, and appealing in the instance of rejection requires a lot of time and energy that many shippers do not have.

Nonetheless, FedEx and UPS provide a money-back guarantee for on-time deliveries and offer refunds if they fail to meet their promises. But they don’t always automatically give you these results.

A shipping audit assesses where you are being overcharged and uncovers service failures and non-compliance with contract terms.

While this is a time-consuming manual process, a shipping audit service like Sifted’s automated parcel audit can track potential refunds and file claims on your behalf!

Visibility Into Shipping Spend

Visibility into shipping spend can help shippers identify inefficiencies in logistics operations and identify the measures they can take to achieve the desired results. For example, Logistics Intelligence (LI) can compare actual shipping costs with the budget and identify a multi-carrier mix to yield low-cost transport alternatives.

Sifted logistics engineering allows you to model different contract terms and project how it would affect your overall cost for multiple carriers.

 

Choose Sifted’s Carrier Management Tools for Informed Decision-Making

A carrier management software (also known as a carrier management system) provides complete visibility over your shipping operations so you can plan ahead more effectively. It also helps you enforce rate compliance and ensures your own compliance across all your carriers to make informed business decisions.

Sifted’s Carrier Management Suite offers a complete way to streamline how you manage your carrier operations and contracts. Its contract monitoring and rate management features enable you to keep track of volume-based pricing penalties and alerts you, so you don’t fall within negotiated tiers.

Unlock discounts and reshape your carrier contracts using Sifted’s contract modeling software. 

Topics: Carrier Management

Check out related resources at Sifted.

What Happens If UPS Lost Your Package?

What Happens If UPS Lost Your Package?

If your tracking hasn’t updated and the delivery date has passed, you may be wondering: Did UPS lose my ...
Read More
Parcel Fraud Prevention: Protect Your Shipping Accounts

Parcel Fraud Prevention: Protect Your Shipping Accounts

Parcel fraud isn’t always dramatic. It doesn’t always look like stolen trailers or high-profile cargo theft. More ...
Read More
How to File FedEx Claims and Recover Lost Revenue Faster

How to File FedEx Claims and Recover Lost Revenue Faster

Lost or damaged shipments are frustrating. If you’re searching for how to file a FedEx claim, check your FedEx ...
Read More
2026 Parcel Shipping Glossary: Key Terms A–Z

2026 Parcel Shipping Glossary: Key Terms A–Z

In 2026, the language of logistics has evolved, and if you don’t understand the terminology, you can’t fully ...
Read More
Do UPS & FedEx Deliver on Weekends?

Do UPS & FedEx Deliver on Weekends?

Do UPS & FedEx Deliver on Weekends? If your customers are ordering seven days a week, they expect delivery ...
Read More
Carrier Mix Optimization: A Shipper’s Guide for 2026

Carrier Mix Optimization: A Shipper’s Guide for 2026

Carrier mix optimization has become a defining factor in parcel performance. Between annual General Rate Increases ...
Read More
Parcel Audit: A Practical Guide to Cutting Shipping Costs

Parcel Audit: A Practical Guide to Cutting Shipping Costs

Shipping invoices are rarely reviewed line by line, but they should be. Parcel pricing is complex, and even ...
Read More
What Are UPS Access Points and How Do They Work?

What Are UPS Access Points and How Do They Work?

As eCommerce volume continues to grow, last-mile delivery challenges increase. Failed delivery attempts drive up ...
Read More
FedEx Additional Handling Surcharge: 2026 Guide

FedEx Additional Handling Surcharge: 2026 Guide

The FedEx additional handling surcharge is one of the most common, and misunderstood, fees impacting parcel ...
Read More
What Is a Fuel Surcharge and How Does It Impact Your Shipping Costs?

What Is a Fuel Surcharge and How Does It Impact Your Shipping Costs?

Fuel surcharges are one of the most common accessorials of parcel shipping costs. For many shippers, they quietly ...
Read More
The State of Parcel Shipping: Growth, Pressure, and What Comes Next

The State of Parcel Shipping: Growth, Pressure, and What Comes Next

A New Era of Shipping Demands a New Way to Manage It Parcel shipping has quietly grown into one of the largest ...
Read More
FedEx Rewards Explained: How the Program Works for Shippers

FedEx Rewards Explained: How the Program Works for Shippers

FedEx Rewards is a loyalty program for enrolled business shippers, not individual consumers Points are earned on ...
Read More
No results found.

Profile Monitoring
Get always-on monitoring across cost-sensitive KPIs

Scenario Modeling
Test supply chain adjustments in a virtual sandbox

Carrier Management
Gain transparency into carrier performance and costs

Monitoring via Alerts
Stay ahead of every change in your parcel operation

Accounting Automation
Automate the manual and error prone processes

Reporting & Analytics
Centralize insights, visualize trends, and create reports

3PL Brand Management
Simplify and accelerate your pricing + billing workflows

SiftedAI Copilot
Have access to an always-on logistics analyst

Use Cases

For Finance Pros
Control shipping spend with automated intelligence

For Logistics Pros
Oversee shipping spend and performance across carriers

For Executives
Get clear visibility into parcel spend, risk and performance

For Retail
Control shipping cost and performance across carriers

For Manufacturing
Manage complex parcel spend with operational clarity

For Health & Life Sciences
Increase oversight into critical shipment performance

For 3PLs
Optimize margin and transparency across brands

For PE Firms
Analyze and act on parcel data to protect EBITDA

Blog
Discover news, tips, and industry best practices

DIM Weight Calculator
See how DIM impacts your shipping costs

Podcast
Hear from industry experts on LeaderShipping

Case Studies
Learn how other brands use
Logistics Intelligence

Carbon Calculator
Calculate CO2 emissions to reduce impact

Guides
Download free reports and
expert how-tos

Frequently Asked Questions
Explore top questions from shippers evaluating SiftedAI

Unboxed Newsletter
Subscribe for parcel news, predictions & tips

Logistics Intelligence
For parcel shippers

Let's get you to the right place!

SIFTEDAI
New & Improved Logistics Intelligence Platform

Not sure if you have an account? Email [email protected].