Monthly Product Demo Register Now

Sifted logo

Amazon FBA vs. FBM

May 25, 2022

9 min read

Amazon FBA vs. FBM Defined

If you’re looking to launch your eCommerce business on Amazon, you need to decide on the fulfillment option for your store. The Seller Central program offers three fulfillment programs to choose from, namely:

  • Fulfillment by Amazon
  • Fulfillment by Merchant
  • Seller Fulfilled Prime

In this article, we’ll compare and contrast the first two fulfillment programs to help you find the right option for your business.

Even Amazon makes mistakes! Gain insights into money that is owed to you with Sifted’s Amazon audit.

Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA)

Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) enables independent retailers to send their products to Amazon’s fulfillment centers. From there, Amazon stores them and picks, packs, and delivers them to the customer.

eCommerce businesses have been using FBA since 2006 to sell products without the need for their own warehouse and order fulfillment process.

Amazon Fulfillment by Merchant (FBM)

Amazon Fulfillment by Merchant (FBM) allows sellers to use their own warehouse facilities and shipping service (or a third-party logistics service) to deliver orders to their customers.

Unlike Seller Fulfilled Prime (SFP) and Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA), FBM sellers don’t have the advantage of being a Prime Seller.

Pros and Cons of Amazon FBA

PROS:

  • Amazon Prime Badge: As an FBA seller, you can sell to Amazon Prime customers. With over 110 million Amazon Prime subscribers in the United States alone, the Amazon Prime badge gives a serious boost to the sales potential of your Amazon store items.
  • Buy Box: It is the white box shown on the Amazon product detail page which brings in serious cash flow to your business. However, its eligibility requires you to meet Amazon’s performance-based requirements.
  • Amazon’s Low Shipping Rates: Amazon FBA sellers have access to Amazon’s state-of-the-art order fulfillment system as well as its network of shipping services, enabling them to spend less on shipping fees.
  • Prime Shipping: FBA products are eligible for Prime Shipping. As a result, you’ll be able to offer 2-day shipping to your Amazon Prime customers with no extra charges.
  • Worry-free inventory and logistics: FBA is a straightforward solution for entrepreneurs and SMBs that would rather outsource their fulfillment services because they don’t have the resources to run their own order fulfillment process.

With FBA, you don’t have to worry about picking, packing, hiring inventory management, and communicating with shipping carriers and customers. Amazon takes care of the order fulfillment process, while you focus on other business activities like sourcing, manufacturing, and product development.

  • Amazon handles customer service and returns: With FBA, Amazon takes care of customer service, returns, refunds, and exchanges.
  • Multi-Channel Fulfillment (MCF): By paying MCF fees, Amazon lets you sell your products through other sales channels such as eBay, on top of the Amazon marketplace. Plus, your inventory items from Amazon’s warehouses are directly shipped to customers on other channels.

 

CONS:

 

  • Less control over inventory: With FBA, you get less control over your inventory. This means you can visit and inspect your inventory location.
  • Cost fluctuations: FBA inventory storage fees are affected by seasonal demands.
  • Meet FBA requirements: With FBA, you have to meet strict FBA labeling and warehousing requirements to get your products accepted.
  • No control over customer support and returns: You can’t directly communicate with your customers and provide support. Moreover, you are exposed to customer fraud because you receive all returns in a box with no way to tell which items are tied to which order.

Pros and Cons of Amazon FBM

PROS:

  • More inventory control: With FBM, you have full control over your inventory i.e. you don’t store your products at Amazon’s fulfillment centers. You have your product listings on Amazon. You pick, pack, and ship products, decide what items are sent to which customer, and track your orders.

Additionally, you’ll be able to sell your inventory items on multiple eCommerce platforms.

  • Complete control over branding: Unlike FBA, you’re able to personalize your order fulfillment process when you use your own brand packaging and marketing inserts in your packaging. This also gives FBM sellers greater control over the customer experience.
  • More Control over Returns: With FBM, you are able to directly handle any refunds and returns. You’ll be able to see product and order information, helping you catch and minimize the risk of customer fraud.
  • Lower shipping costs: FBM charges you less Amazon fees with Prime standards of shipping. This fulfillment method is great for eCommerce stores who can fulfill their orders cheaper than FBA fees. FBM sellers also avoid paying additional fees such as returns processing fees and long-term storage fees.

It also protects your business from unexpected changes in Amazon pricing policies.

Moreover, you can negotiate favorable shipping fees with your shipping carrier.

  • Skip FBA requirements: With FBM, you don’t need to meet the strict FBA labeling and warehousing requirements to get your products accepted.

CONS:

  • Cost Structure: FBM sellers have to handle the fulfillment fees which can cost more than usual if the customer wants 1-2 day delivery. In addition to this, there are Amazon charges for items sold, referrals, and monthly subscriptions.

Moreover, you have to handle your own storage, labor, product packaging, and shipping, plus managing these costs.

  • Complete responsibility to fulfill orders: You have to handle any issue that arises from the moment the delivery leaves the warehouse to the point it reaches the customers’ address. It is the Merchant Fulfilled Network’s (MFN) responsibility to communicate with the customer for handling refunds, returns, and exchanges.
  • Takes more time: You’ll need to take the time to keep your order fulfillment process working. This includes managing people, warehouses, logistics, and handling customer service. 

Which should Amazon sellers use?

You should opt for FBA if: 

  • You’re a high-volume seller.
  • You sell products that are low-priced and have smaller dimensions (size and weight).
  • You’re willing to give control over your inventory and order fulfillment process to Amazon
  • You can’t hire a third-party logistics company or manage your logistics operations including inventory control and returns processing.

You should opt for FBM if:

  • You want complete control over your brand packaging, marketing, and customer experience.
  • You want more control over your inventory
  • You can offer great customer support to your customers and can handle returns and refunds.
  • You’re looking to sell on multiple eCommerce platforms such as eBay and Walmart Marketplace.

Audit your Amazon data and identify errors with Sifted

Your Amazon FBA vs. FBM decision must consider factors such as shipping fees, branding, and inventory control.

Regardless of which Amazon order fulfillment program you choose, you should take steps to stay on top of your Amazon fees, inventory management, and refunds. Around 1 to 3 percent of Amazon sales are affected by discrepancies which means Amazon may mistakenly overcharge sellers, issue incorrect refunds, and mishandle inventory.

Sifted’s Marketplace Intelligence product is an all-in-one platform that gives you the tools to manage your Amazon business. Its Amazon audit enables you to identify Amazon’s errors and get the money owed to you.

Ready to optimize the bottom line of your Amazon store? Sign up for free!

Topics: Amazon
Topics

Check out related resources at Sifted.

Monumental Rate Hikes: 2023 UPS & FedEx General Rate Increase (GRI) Analysis

Monumental Rate Hikes: 2023 UPS & FedEx General Rate Increase (GRI) Analysis

It’s here. UPS & FedEx have announced an average General Rate Increase of 6.9%. Actual impact to most ...
Read More
Freight Transportation: The Ins, the Outs, and How it Affects Logistics

Freight Transportation: The Ins, the Outs, and How it Affects Logistics

What Is Freight Transportation? Freight transportation is the movement of goods, merchandise, and cargo using ...
Read More
What is a UPS Residential Surcharge?

What is a UPS Residential Surcharge?

As a shipper, you can request delivery to any address. However, when your packages are shipped to a residential ...
Read More
Shipping Contracts: Key Responsibilities You Can’t Miss

Shipping Contracts: Key Responsibilities You Can’t Miss

What Is a Shipping Contract? Whether you are a high-volume shipper or run a small business, you must understand ...
Read More
Logistics Planning: Why Your Business Should Prioritize It

Logistics Planning: Why Your Business Should Prioritize It

What Is Logistics Planning? Logistics planning is a planning process that helps businesses achieve their logistics ...
Read More
How Companies Can Reduce Parcel Shipping Costs in 2022

How Companies Can Reduce Parcel Shipping Costs in 2022

Different Factors to Consider One of the top priorities for eCommerce businesses and shippers alike is finding ...
Read More
How Predictive Analytics Helps Improve Supply Chain Operations

How Predictive Analytics Helps Improve Supply Chain Operations

What Is Supply Chain Predictive Analytics? Supply chain predictive analytics use historical and present data and ...
Read More
Cyber Monday and Tips for Shippers to Stay Ahead of the Curve

Cyber Monday and Tips for Shippers to Stay Ahead of the Curve

What Is Cyber Monday? Cyber Monday is a major eCommerce-exclusive shopping event that falls on the first Monday ...
Read More
Do Fedex, USPS, UPS do Black Friday Mail Delivery?

Do Fedex, USPS, UPS do Black Friday Mail Delivery?

What Is Black Friday? Black Friday is one of the busiest shopping days of the year in the United States, and falls ...
Read More
Sifted at PARCEL Forum ‘22: Our Recap

Sifted at PARCEL Forum ‘22: Our Recap

In October, Sifted traveled to Chicago to attend PARCEL Forum ‘22, the largest event for eCommerce-centric B2B and ...
Read More
Delivery Exceptions: How to Handle Them

Delivery Exceptions: How to Handle Them

What Is a Delivery Exception? A delivery exception (also known as shipment exception) is when package delivery ...
Read More
The Importance of Business Intelligence in Supply Chains

The Importance of Business Intelligence in Supply Chains

What is Business Intelligence? Business intelligence (BI) is a method of collecting and analyzing business data to ...
Read More
Black Friday and How Shippers Can Combat Potential Shipping Delays

Black Friday and How Shippers Can Combat Potential Shipping Delays

What is Black Friday? Black Friday an annual shopping event that takes place the day after Thanksgiving. It is ...
Read More

How Sifted Works

Connect to
your account

Sync
your data

Power your
dashboards

Get Your Logistics
Intelligence Demo

Strategic ways to prevent loss down the line

Services you could be utilizing right now for savings

Ways to cut material costs without cutting quality

Are you an FBM (fulfillment by merchant) Amazon seller?

Check out our Marketplace Intelligence solutions to protect your bottom line.

Shipping Insights & Alerts
Get updates and track the things impacting your business most

Decision Support
See how supply chain adjustments pay off before you pay out

Carrier Management
Streamline how you manage your carrier operations and contracts

Business Automation
Let software do what it does better than people can

Seller Insights
Measure and monitor with confidence.

Sales Visualization
Shed new light on your sales data.

Fee Analyzer
Understand the impact of ever-changing FBA fees.

FBA Audit & Recovery
Secure money you’re owed from Amazon.

Blog
Discover news, tips, and industry best practices

DIM Weight Calculator
See how DIM is impacting you

Customer Stories
Learn how other brands use
Logistics Intelligence

Carbon Calculator
Calculate your CO2 Emissions

Guides
Download free reports and expert how-tos

Demo
Get a personalized tour of our software

Logistics Intelligence
For parcel shippers

Marketplace Intelligence
For Amazon FBA sellers

Let's get you to the right place!

SIFTED DASHBOARDS
For parcel shippers

AMAZON Marketplace Intelligence

Not sure if you have an account? Email [email protected].