Live in Beta: SiftedAI Copilot, Your Always-On Logistics Analyst Learn More

Sifted logo

Shipper & Carrier Agreement vs Contract: What’s the Difference?

Dec 14, 2020

5 min read

One conversation that comes up over and over in my chats with shippers is about their carrier contracts. And most shippers are surprised to learn that their deal with their carrier is not a contract at all — it’s an agreement.

What’s the difference? An agreement is less formal and binding — both of you can make changes at any time. A contract has locked-in terms, start and end dates, and other commitments. An agreement is a formal understanding that you’ll work together, barring certain issues and events.

 

What Is a Carrier Agreement?

A carrier agreement is a documented promise between a shipper and a carrier that the shipper will use the carrier’s services in exchange for a discount on those services. A shipper of any size will typically have an agreement with at least one carrier to reduce their shipping costs.

 

What Is in a Carrier Agreement?

A typical carrier agreement will contain the rates for carrier services, including any discounts and minimum charges that the shipper can expect. It will also contain language from the carrier restricting certain practices and activities. They are usually highly complex with many caveats and conditions that will affect every package you send differently, so it’s crucial to make sure you understand all the details.

 

How Often Should You Optimize a Carrier Agreement?

While a full optimization is only needed once a year, you should be tweaking your carrier agreement in response to carrier pricing changes four to six times a year. By doing this, you’ll keep the value of your discounts as close as possible to what you optimized.

2020 has brought historic (and rapidly occurring) changes for shippers to contend with, including suspended service guarantees and a double whammy of peak surcharges for both pandemic-related shipping and the 2020 holiday season. Not to mention an overrun shipping network.

How have these changes affected your shipping spend? Is your effective discount still what you thought it was? Do you know what your effective discount is?

The fact is that your carrier can change your pricing at any time because, again, you have an agreement, not a contract. But that means you can ask for changes at any time as well.

FBA vs FBM

10 Ways to Future-Proof Your Business

How Should You Approach Your Carrier About Adjusting Your Carrier Agreement?

Don’t make a move without all the information you need to make a strong case. Ensure you have your latest data and trends in hand — not last quarter’s or even last month’s.

Then make sure you know how it impacts your spend and what needs to change to get your pricing closer to what you optimized. Contact your rep and work with them to adjust the agreement to reflect what’s happening in your business (and theirs) today.

 

Careful Observation of Your Data Keeps Your Spend Down

Smaller shippers are often too overwhelmed by the daily grind of running their business to keep up with their shipping data, while larger shippers might find that the sheer volume of their data makes it difficult to work with and interpret. But to maintain a strong discount and keep your shipping spend down, it’s imperative to understand your data — and be able to act on it — at all times.

Before you optimize, make sure you have all the information you need about surcharges. Find it in our eBook, 5 Budget-Busting Surcharges & How to Lower Them.

Topics: Carrier Optimization, Contract Optimization

Check out related resources at Sifted.

How to File FedEx Claims and Recover Lost Revenue Faster

How to File FedEx Claims and Recover Lost Revenue Faster

Lost or damaged shipments are frustrating. If you’re searching for how to file a FedEx claim, check your FedEx ...
Read More
2026 Parcel Shipping Glossary: Key Terms A–Z

2026 Parcel Shipping Glossary: Key Terms A–Z

In 2026, the language of logistics has evolved, and if you don’t understand the terminology, you can’t fully ...
Read More
Do UPS & FedEx Deliver on Weekends?

Do UPS & FedEx Deliver on Weekends?

Do UPS & FedEx Deliver on Weekends? If your customers are ordering seven days a week, they expect delivery ...
Read More
Carrier Mix Optimization: A Shipper’s Guide for 2026

Carrier Mix Optimization: A Shipper’s Guide for 2026

Carrier mix optimization has become a defining factor in parcel performance. Between annual General Rate Increases ...
Read More
Parcel Audit: A Practical Guide to Cutting Shipping Costs

Parcel Audit: A Practical Guide to Cutting Shipping Costs

Shipping invoices are rarely reviewed line by line, but they should be. Parcel pricing is complex, and even ...
Read More
What Are UPS Access Points and How Do They Work?

What Are UPS Access Points and How Do They Work?

As eCommerce volume continues to grow, last-mile delivery challenges increase. Failed delivery attempts drive up ...
Read More
FedEx Additional Handling Surcharge: 2026 Guide

FedEx Additional Handling Surcharge: 2026 Guide

The FedEx additional handling surcharge is one of the most common, and misunderstood, fees impacting parcel ...
Read More
What Is a Fuel Surcharge and How Does It Impact Your Shipping Costs?

What Is a Fuel Surcharge and How Does It Impact Your Shipping Costs?

Fuel surcharges are one of the most common accessorials of parcel shipping costs. For many shippers, they quietly ...
Read More
The State of Parcel Shipping: Growth, Pressure, and What Comes Next

The State of Parcel Shipping: Growth, Pressure, and What Comes Next

A New Era of Shipping Demands a New Way to Manage It Parcel shipping has quietly grown into one of the largest ...
Read More
FedEx Rewards Explained: How the Program Works for Shippers

FedEx Rewards Explained: How the Program Works for Shippers

FedEx Rewards is a loyalty program for enrolled business shippers, not individual consumers Points are earned on ...
Read More
UPS Mail Innovations: What It Is, How It Works, and When to Use It

UPS Mail Innovations: What It Is, How It Works, and When to Use It

UPS Mail Innovations is often chosen for one reason: lower shipping costs. But for many shippers, those savings ...
Read More
Meet Sifted at Manifest 2026 in Las Vegas—Booth #1022

Meet Sifted at Manifest 2026 in Las Vegas—Booth #1022

We’re excited to be exhibiting at Manifest 2026, the premier global conference for supply chain and logistics ...
Read More
No results found.

Profile Monitoring
Get always-on monitoring across your cost-sensitive KPIs

Scenario Modeling
Test strategic investment decisions out in a virtual sandbox

Carrier Management
Gain transparency into carrier performance, pricing, and billing

Monitoring via Alerts
Stay ahead of every change in your parcel operation

Accounting Automation
Automate the manual and error prone processes

Reporting & Analytics
Centralize insights, visualize trends, and create custom reports

3PL Brand Management
Simplify and accelerate your pricing + billing workflows

SiftedAI Copilot
Have access to an always-on logistics analyst

Use Cases

For Finance Pros
Control and forecast shipping spend with automated intelligence

For Logistics Pros
Oversee shipping spend and performance across carriers

For Executives
Get clear visibility into parcel spend, risk and performance

Blog
Discover news, tips, and industry best practices

DIM Weight Calculator
See how DIM is impacting you

Podcast
Hear from industry experts on LeaderShipping

Case Studies
Learn how other brands use
Logistics Intelligence

Carbon Calculator
Calculate your CO2 Emissions

Guides
Download free reports and
expert how-tos

Frequently Asked Questions
Explore top questions from shippers evaluating SiftedAI

About Sifted
Get to know Logistics Intelligence

Unboxed Newsletter
Subscribe for parcel news, predictions & tips

Logistics Intelligence
For parcel shippers

Let's get you to the right place!

SIFTEDAI
New & Improved Logistics Intelligence Platform

Not sure if you have an account? Email [email protected].