Sifted vs. TransImpact
Sifted and TransImpact both serve the Logistics Intelligence market, but their focus sets them apart. TransImpact positions itself as a parcel spend management company, with tools primarily centered around cost reduction. Sifted, while excelling in spend management, goes beyond to optimize operations, improve efficiency, and enhance customer experience—all within one unified platform. With Sifted, you’re not just managing costs—you’re transforming your logistics strategy into a competitive advantage.
Key Differentiators
Comprehensive Optimization vs. Cost Savings Focus –
- Sifted goes beyond spend management to optimize operations, improve efficiency, and enhance customer experience. Sifted integrates cost-saving tools with advanced features for 100% parcel optimization.
- TransImpact primarily focuses on parcel spend management, delivering strong tools for cost reduction but without the broader operational and customer-focused capabilities of Sifted.
Customizable vs. Generic Dashboards –
- Sifted allows you to customize your in-platform experience by selecting and focusing on key performance indicators (KPIs) that are relevant to your needs. Sifted also has robust filtering capabilities that carry throughout the platform & allow you to drill down into what matters most to your business.
- TransImpact has similar analytics and insights to Sifted, but does not allow for customization, rather has generic dashboards that apply to all clients. There are limited filtering capabilities throughout the platform as well.
Predictive Modeling vs. Static Analytics –
- The Sifted platform not only has in-depth reporting & analytics, but also features robust in-platform scenario modeling tools to simulate optimization opportunities. You can try out and see the impact of new warehouse locations, packaging sizes, service types, etc.
- TransImpact offers similar strong analytics and reporting capabilities to Sifted, but lacks the advanced modeling features to allow you to solve for inefficiencies in-platform. With TransImpact, If you want to run one of these scenarios you have to ask them to run a manual, behind-the scenes-report.
SaaS vs. Gainshare AND Flat-Free Pricing –
- Sifted operates on a SaaS, or software as a service, business model. You pay a flat subscription fee in exchange for licenses to use the software. This allows for a broader range of service optimizations and offers a more client-centric, data-driven approach.
- TransImpact not only charges a flat-fee for platform usage, but also implements a gainshare model on top of it. With this approach, a percentage of savings recovered is kept by TransImpact rather than going back in your pocket.
Where Sifted Wins
Sifted’s platform is complete with advanced analytics and always-on monitoring to keep track of the KPIs important to you and your business. You can use it to:
- See data and details normalized across carriers
- Receive personalized operational + savings recommendations + how to achieve them
- Get real-time actionable alerts when you need to take action
- Build custom reports with robust filtering capabilities
Sifted’s robust modeling tools are second to none in the industry; they allow you to simulate a variety of high-stakes scenarios in a virtual sandbox. With them you can:
- Simulate and model alternative warehouse locations based on zones
- Test different sizes and weights for packages most affected by oversize fees
- Identify potential vulnerabilities in your supply chain related to fee hikes
- Make service type adjustments by analyzing the most cost-effective mode
- Model the cost impact of volume shifts, to aid in strategic planning
Sifted’s Carrier Bill Pay is great for anyone wanting to save time on data entry, avoid late payment penalties or maximize discounts. By automating the way you pay, you can:
- Eliminate late payment fees to save money
- Free up your staff and focus on productivity – not extra paperwork
- Let software do the hard work for you
Product Capabilities*
| Sifted | TransImpact | |
|---|---|---|
| Profile Monitoring | ||
| Shipping Health Score | X | |
| Shipping Analytics | X | X |
| Notifications | X | X |
| Scenario Modeling | ||
| Packaging Modeling | X | |
| Network Optimization | X | |
| Service Type Optimization | X | |
| GRI Impact Analysis | Software | People |
| Demand Surcharge Analysis | X | |
| Carrier Management | ||
| Contract Modeling | X | |
| Contract Monitoring | X | |
| Contract Compliance | X | X |
| Time in Transit Analysis | X | X |
| Accounting Automation | ||
| Audit | X | X |
| Bill Pay | X | |
| Claims | X | |
| GL Coding | X | X |
| Package Level Details | X | X |
| Contract Negotiation Support | ||
| Savings Analysis | X | X |
| Negotiation Strategy | X | X |
| Support | X | X |
| Re-Rates | X | X |
*Some capabilities are product tier dependent.
Reviews
| Sifted | TransImpact | |
|---|---|---|
| G2 | • 36 Reviews • 4.6 / 5 Stars • Winter, Spring, Summer and Fall 2024 Leader in Multicarrier Parcel Management | N/A |
| Capterra | • 44 Reviews • 4.8 / 5 Stars | N/A |
| TrustPilot | • 22 Reviews • 4.1 / 5 Stars | N/A |